WhatsappEarlier I dealt with the morality of Trump’s plan for Gazans to emigrate from Gaza.
Now I want to go deeper into the Gaza issue that has rarely been dealt with – Are Gazans Refugees or Is Gaza Their Land? You Can’t Have It Both Ways
One of the most absurd logical contradictions in the entire Israel-Gaza narrative is this: Are the Gazans refugees, or is Gaza their land?
Think about it. The same people who call for a “Free Palestine” will claim that Gaza is the ancestral homeland of the “Palestinian people,” while in the same breath, they will call Gazans refugees.
So which is it? If Gaza is their land, then they are not refugees. And if they are refugees, then Gaza is not their land.
This isn’t a small inconsistency—it’s at the core of the entire lie the world has been sold about the so-called “palestinian” refugees. Because the truth is, the vast majority of the people living in Gaza today are not originally from Gaza.
The Historical Truth: Gazans Are Not Native to Gaza
The fact is that a vast majority of Arab Muslims moved into the land of Israel from other Arab-Muslim countries over the past 200 years is well documented. The official immigration numbers show that between 1840 and 1948, approximately one million Arab Muslims immigrated to the Jewish ancestral homeland from surrounding Arab countries.
Why? Because Jewish development of the land under the British Mandate and the Jews who moved back home to Israel during that time period created economic opportunities that never existed before. This attracted massive waves of Arab immigration from Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, and the Arabian Peninsula.
And here’s the kicker: Even Hamas leaders admit this!
In a now-infamous speech during the 2014 military operation, Hamas leader Fathi Hammad publicly pleaded for help from Egypt declaring:
“Who are the Palestinians? We are Egyptians! We are Saudis! We are Arabs!”
So let’s stop pretending that Gaza is their “homeland.” The truth is, most of the population came from elsewhere and has no deep historical roots in Gaza.
Trump’s Plan: A Return Home, Not a “Displacement”
President Trump’s plan to relocate Gazans to other Arab-Muslim countries is not some radical idea—it is actually a correction of history. These are not people being expelled from their homeland. They are simply returning to them to where they originally came from, if those countries would accept them.
The Arab world has 22 countries and over 5 million square miles of land—more than enough space to accommodate their own people. If Gazans want to return to Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, or anywhere else in the Arab world, they should be free to do so. That is their real home.
But if they want to stay in Gaza? Then they must accept one simple reality: Gaza is Jewish land, and Israel is sovereign over it. To remain, they must agree to live in peace. Otherwise, they have no reason to live with us.
The Big Lie Exposed
The world has been told two contradictory lies for decades:
1. Gazans are an indigenous people with a deep historical connection to Gaza.
2. Gazans are refugees who must be given a “right of return” to Israel.
Both cannot be true. If they are indigenous to Gaza, they are not refugees. If they are refugees, then Gaza is not their land. The entire argument collapses under its own contradictions.
And now, thanks to President Trump’s leadership, the world is finally being forced to confront this truth.
The Jewish people are returning to Gaza.
The Arab Muslims who came from Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and elsewhere will have the opportunity to go back home.
And for the first time in decades, there is a real path to peace and quiet—because peace is only possible when the truth is acknowledged.
Bottom line, it’s time to stop the lies. Gaza is Jewish, an integral part of the land of Israel throughout history, thousands of years before Muhammad invented Islam and the first Arab stepped into Israel. (For more information on Jewish history in Gaza click on the link in the comments below)
And, no, this is not similar to the call for Jews “to go back to Europe”. We were slaughtered in Europe because they called or us to leave Europe and go back home to Palestine, the Roman named territory of the Land of Israel, our ancestral homeland that can not be denied.
